Livingston

Oct
08
2007

Corporations Have Anti-Social Media Cultures

Last week Jim Tobin tagged me in an article on “Why Social Media Marketing is Hard for Corporations.” A very timely post, as this topic has been bantered about quite a bit in the back channel over the past couple of weeks between myself, Debbie Weil, CC Chapman, and others.

Sixty years of mass communication rules will take a long time to un-write no matter how hot social media becomes. Corporation cultures just don’t change very easily.

And to be frank — though more companies are engaging — it’s not an all consuming flood. Why? It flies in the face of everything we as marketers have been taught. Consider Jim’s post:

Professional marketers were trained to talk. They were the “spinners”, the ones who could come up with the talking points, the unique selling proposition. Whether a customer was ready to listen wasn’t a big concern. We just had to figure out what shows they were watching and hope they stayed on the couch.

Consider that the marketing discipline most impacted by social media is PR… And PR people are the most resistant to the changes demanded by this new era. Reluctant PR pros are really a reflection of the general conservative corporate CxO suite, which has been taught to control the message from the time executives entered business school all the way through to their last promotion.

The Adoption Curve

It’s early in the adoption curve. Social media is just beginning to ramp-up. Who knows how quickly it will accelerate, but is apparent that businesses are seriously considering social media. They are just beginning to adopt new media forms.

S-Curve

Right now in 2007 most corporate cultures work against the successful adoption of social media. But before adoption occurs on a mass level, companies have to want to move in that direction. Why are most companies resistant? These seem to be the greatest cultural barriers:

With the current corporate culture when companies do engage, we have astroturfing incidents or blatantly contrived content that turns away potentially interested parties. Rare is the corporate social media effort that begins with instant success. This is both an education issue and a cultural issue.

As the S-curve ramps up over time and social media becomes more pervasive there will be little choice. Then social media principles will either be applied and learned, or avoided, resulting in brand damage.

For those of us in PR and marketing that already get it, our job is to evangelize and keep the lights on. Without a path, it is much harder to find your way. Thus the great challenge for social media marketers: How to enable businesses to successfully adopt the social media ethos while demonstrating ROI? More on the social media marketer’s role next week.

Related reading: Wanna pass the 2.0 Go?

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
by Geoff Livingston | Internet Marketing |

11 Responses to “Corporations Have Anti-Social Media Cultures”

  • Andrew Badera Says:

    October 8th, 2007 at 6:26 am

    Do you feel that social media has a place in ALL types of corporations? What about those that don’t have a particularly public face — those like, for instance, my employer, a managed eye car benefit/retail/optical laboratory concern, who, at the corporate level, need to sell themselves on more of a B2B level, rather than the unwashed masses. (Yes on the retail side of course they appeal more directly to the masses, but that’s not, by far, the largest aspect of the business.)

  • Jim Long Says:

    October 8th, 2007 at 6:28 am

    Conversations don’t happen from the top down. When I evangelize social media at my current employer, I either encounter the “tilted head - curious dog” look, or ham-fisted attempts to ape and mimic what’s happening organically on the social web.

  • Geoff Livingston Says:

    October 8th, 2007 at 8:50 am

    Andrew: I actually think that B2B organizations have more to gain from social media than traditional consumer companies. First of all, they are required to develop very specific subject matter expertise to serve high dollar, niches. This gives them great fodder to blog about. The caveat is that their community of buyers is online. I have a link to a study on this topic which I’ll have to delve up.

    Jim: NBC Universal is notoriously backwards on the content issue. Copyright protection is still the company’s mantra and it refuses to play in viral environments. NBC Universal has a tough road to hoe in this space.

  • RichardatDELL Says:

    October 8th, 2007 at 9:03 pm

    Geoff

    this is an excellent piece and certainly underscores some of the “inherent” and “evolving” challenges.

    And when you talk about keeping the lights on and evangelizing, Id also add that in clearing the path we must always be showing progress, results and eventually the more holy grail of a robust and coherent total ( and likely quite different) ROI package. In the meantime positive and successful stories do help.

    Finally, you have to wonder sometimes too if the impediment is more than organizational or cultural. There can also be a the threat-challenge-fear factor of unlearning and learning anew. Whether in social media or just generally in business and career training, that human instinct to stick with what we learned and know can be pretty strong.

    Cant wait to read the rest!

  • Show me the money… not the smiley faces. « ITSinsider Says:

    October 8th, 2007 at 9:31 pm

    Kramer auto Pingback[...] Might want to check out what Geoff Livingston over at the Buzz Bin has to say about the dynamics of social media adoption — in short there are no quick successes but there can be negative implications for corporations that do not adapt. http://www.livingstonbuzz.com/blog/2007/10/08/corporations-have-anti-social-cultures/ [...]

  • Perceptive Travel Blog » Blog Archive » 6 ways travelers can use social media Says:

    October 8th, 2007 at 9:51 pm

    [...] diktat. You write the book, give the advice, take the pictures. The average travel-related corporation may not really like it, and many respected travel gurus don’t either, but it is here to [...]

  • The Death of PR? Ummm, no Says:

    October 9th, 2007 at 6:06 am

    [...] our world who are not getting social media, whether they are ignorant or scared. Geoff Livingstone argues this point yesterday. Tom is fortunate because being in Silicon Valley he gets to see the cutting edge of both [...]

  • The Impact of the "In Crowd" » The Buzz Bin Says:

    October 10th, 2007 at 7:42 am

    [...] MySpace members, Flickr photos and thousands of YouTube videos available, it’s clear that adoption is becoming more mainstream. Slowly, more corporations and individuals are becoming an interactive part of the Web 2.0 [...]

  • JMW Kommunikation » Blog Archive » PR-byrÃ¥ers och företagens roll i ljuset av sociala medier Says:

    October 10th, 2007 at 11:04 am

    [...] här och nu men ger er chansen att lägga ert eget pussel. Geoff Livingston skriver nämligen väldigt intressant och utmanande om pr-branschens egen roll vid implementeringen av sociala medier som mediekanal. Att [...]

  • Evangelize! » The Buzz Bin Says:

    October 15th, 2007 at 5:22 am

    [...] Monday we discussed the challenges facing business adoption of social media tools and principles. To get to the other side, social media consultants need to [...]

  • Media Orchard, by the Idea Grove: Media News, Marketing Views, Celebrity Culture, Political Spin Says:

    November 22nd, 2007 at 7:17 am

    Kramer auto Pingback[...] check out all these Latin terms that will make you sound smarter than you are (Daily Writing Tips)Corporations don’t get social media and maybe never will (The Buzz Bin)John Mellencamp’s Jena 6 video is idiotic (YouTube)The best media blog on the planet [...]

Leave a Reply